Mother Teresa’s Sainthood Fraud: Did She Do More Harm than Good?

Mother Teresa’s entire name is associated with goodness. “You’re no Mother Teresa,” People scoff when they tell you to do the right thing. 

But was Mother Teresa even a “Mother Teresa?”

Mother Teresa’s Sainthood

A stained glass window of Mother Teresa in the Memorial House in Skopje, Macedonia
Photo Credit: Zvonimir Atletic via Shutterstock.com.

She was celebrated as a saint during her life and canonized as one upon her passing. According to the official story, she dedicated her life to serving the poor, and she even won a Nobel Peace Prize in 1979 for her efforts. 

The Case Against Her Sainthood

A woman holds a photo of Mother Teresa holding a candle outside the Vatican.
Photo Credit: AM113 via Shutterstock.com.

People started questioning Mother Teresa’s motives, and sainthood after renowned Athiest thought leader Christopher Hitchens’ two works, the documentary Hell’s Angel and book The Missionary Position, called some of her practices into question. 

Hitchens’ Claim

Local people in a hospital in one of the poorest regions of India - 2011
Photo Credit: Travel Stock via Shutterstock.com.

Hitchens claimed that Mother Teresa was a fraud. He reported that she purposefully withheld medicine to keep people suffering and housed them in horrific conditions despite having the money to offer something better. 

She Loves Suffering

 The statue of Mother Teresa in the chapel of the Mother House, Kolkata, India at 8 February 2014
Photo Credit; Zvonimir Atletic via Shutterstock.com.

In Hitchens’s view, Mother Teresa behaved like this because she loved suffering. She thought it brought people closer to Jesus. She forced people to suffer for her religious beliefs. 

And She’s a Hypocrite

 Interior of the Memorial House of Mother Teresa in Skopje, North Macedonia.
Photo Credit: Matyas Rehak via Shutterstock.com.

But she changed her view when it came to her own healthcare. She didn’t spend her hospice years in overcrowded, dirty shelters, and she received the best care available for her cancer treatments. 

What’s the Truth?

An unsure woman scratches her head thinking.
Photo Credit: Roman Samborskyi via Shutterstock.com.

Was Mother Teresa a saint or a fraud? The truth is likely somewhere in between. Though there’s some truth to the fraud claims, many are made in a vacuum without nuance and without considering her stated mission or the country/times where she was working. 

A Hospice

A hospice established by Mother Teresa which is now run by missionaries. Photo taken in 2014.
Photo Credit: Zvonimir Atletic via Shutterstock.com.

Mother Teresa’s stated goal was hospice care, but not modern hospice care as we know it.  When she started in the 1950s, hospice was just a place where people go to die. There was no medical component. 

Never a Hospital

A person in a sterile hospital bed on life support surrounded by machines.
Photo Credit: Frame Stock Footage via Shutterstock.com.

Mother Teresa never intended to cure the sick. Her goal was to offer food, shelter, and a bit of comfort to people nearing the end of their lives. 

She Could Have Made It Better

A guilty looking man shrugs his shoulder as if he doesn't really care that what he did is wrong.
Photo Credit: ViDI Studio via Shutterstock.com.

Some of the judgment is fair – Mother Teresa had the funding to improve the hospice. She could have provided better beds, more space, or a variety of other things to ease her patients suffering even more. 

No Painkillers

A medical researcher using a microscope.
Photo Credit: Mongkolchon Akesin via Shutterstock.com.

One of the harshest criticisms against Mother Teresa is the lack of painkillers. Hitchens reported she intentionally withheld them to watch people suffer, as their suffering would bring them (and, as a result, her) closer to God. 

No Access

Woman taking a few capsules from a bottle of over the counter headache medicine.
Photo Credit: engagestock via Shutterstock.com.

In truth, she did offer some painkillers, but they were the over-the-counter kind. As a hospice, not a hospital, she didn’t have access to stronger medicines. 

Why Not Hire Doctors?

A seasoned male doctor in a white coat stands in front of a blurred group of younger residents.
Photo Credit: PeopleImages.com – Yuri A via Shutterstock.com.

The crux of the issue is there’s a lot Mother Teresa could have done differently. She could have hired doctors to prescribe painkillers, though that was outside her stated goal. 

Some Suffered Needlessly

Nuns working at Mother Teresa's hospice in Kolkata.
Photo Credit; Salvacampillo via Shutterstock.com.

Many in her care could have had better outcomes if they had access to medical care. Mother Teresa and her crew refused to transfer patients to real hospitals for better care. Some of these patients weren’t even terminal but didn’t have access to the necessary care that would save their lives. 

Better than Nothing

Impoverished children in India served their school lunches.
Photo Credit: Mohammad Shahnawaz via Shutterstock.com.

Mother Teresa offered immediate attention to the dying poor. Many would say a bed and a hot bowl of soup were far better than the alternative, dying in the sewer. 

On Doing More

A disappointed woman standing with her arms crossed and an annoyed look on her face.
Photo Credit: Dean Drobot via Shutterstock.com.

The critics have a point. She could have done far more. She refused to do anything to help people outside their immediate needs. Mother Teresa did nothing to help people escape poverty or get genuine medical care, and she could have. 

Better Conditions

A hospital in India during the COVID pandemic.
Photo Credit; Sumit Saraswat via Shutterstock.com.

She also failed miserably at providing hygienic conditions for patients. She wouldn’t even allow the nurses to boil needles, causing untold amounts of infections. The living conditions in her hospices were subpar but probably better than the sewer. 

But What Have the Critics Done?

A skeptical looking woman with her arms crossed making a face as if she's not impressed and judging you.
Photo Credit: HBRH via Shutterstock.com.

But what did they do other than judge Mother Teresa? Asking why she didn’t build a hospital is like asking someone who builds a cat rescue why they don’t rescue dogs. A hospital was never the goal. A safe place for the poorest people who couldn’t afford medical care was the goal. 

Her Attitude Problematic

Mother Teresa during her 1986 visit to the White house.
Photo Credit: mark reinstein via Shutterstock.com.

The most significant criticism against Mother Teresa is her attitude. According to an interview by Mary Johnson, someone who worked with Mother Teresa, the idea that the saint “glorified suffering” is true. She didn’t help the poor to truly help them. She only helped them so she could get closer to God. They had to stay “the poor and suffering” for that. 

But it was The Church’s Attitude at the Time

People sitting in the pews of a church.
Photo Credit: muratart via Shutterstock.com.

It’s easy to blame Mother Teresa for this horrible attitude, but we must also look past her to her spiritual directors, who were all pushing the same message. Johnson admitted that she received the same guidance from her directors, that she could only provide immediate assistance and couldn’t do anything to improve people’s lives. 

Mother Teresa Human

A statue depicting Mother Teresa smiling as she holds a baby. Church of Saint Mary of Suffrage in Ravenna.
Photo Credit: Vivida Photo PC via Shutterstock.com.

The truth is Mother Teresa is neither a saint nor a fraud. She was a human, doing the best she could with the information she had available. She made mistakes along the way, but she also did help a lot of people who everyone else ignored. 

Generational Poverty

A woman on the street in Portland holds up a sign saying she's a single mom and needs help.
Photo Credit: Victoria Ditkovsky via Shutterstock.com.

Poverty is a generational problem. Here’s how folks get trapped in cycles of generational poverty

America has a Poverty Trap

hands holding an empty wallet to represent poverty
Photo credit: StanislauV via Shutterstock.com.

We often think of third world countries when we talk about poverty, but it’s thriving right here in the US.

Here’s the truth about America’s Poverty Trap.
 

Things America Could Learn from Western Neighbors

two girls holding up the American flag behind them.
Photo Credit: Red Fox studio via Shutterstock.com.

Is America the greatest country in the world? If it is, why don’t we enjoy the same perks other Western nations do?

Here are great examples of beneficial programs other countries have we wish America would copy

Why More People Are Turning from Religion

A priest with the shadows of innocent children in the background.
Photo Credit: ambrozinio via Shutterstock.com.

Religious groups have long histories of persecuting others. With our modern, interconnected world, more and more people are turning away from these oppressive teachings. 

Here’s why more people are leaving religion

The Most Baffling Reasons to Believe

Portrait of a woman who looks shocked and kind of confused.
Photo Credit: Stockbusters via Shutterstock.com.

Whether you believe in God or not is a personal matter, yet some religious folks can’t fathom that others don’t believe. There confusion often leads them to make up the most ridiculous reasons for believing in God. 

Here, atheists share the strangest arguements for God’s existence they’ve ever heard. 
 

Source: Reddit