Are you a fan of all things macabre? Do you revel in collecting scary movie props and memorabilia, and love finding goodies to add to your collection?
You’ll love the monthly surprise waiting for you with a horror subscription box!
Note: Updated in 2025 to remove defunct boxes and add some new ones!
Hey folks! Transparency Disclosure- Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. That means I’ll receive a small commission if you decide to click on it and buy something. Don’t worry, it doesn’t cost you anything extra!
What’s a Horror Subscription Box?
Horror subscription boxes are monthly gift boxes bursting with the latest in horror entertainment. The boxes may contain games, movies, collectibles, T-shirts, posters, coffee mugs, magnets, and a wide variety of items representing films and literature across the genre.
The fun of a subscription gift box lies in the surprise. Giddy horror fans squeal with delight upon discovering the toys present with each delivery. Purchasing a horror subscription box allows horror fans to recreate the magical anticipation of Christmas morning every month of the year.
The Best Horror Subscription Boxes
Are you ready to gift yourself (or a friend!) spine-tingling anticipation and horrific fun? Check out these top horror subscription boxes for enjoyment that lasts all year long!
Check out these top horror subscription boxes of 2025 for enjoyment that lasts all year long!
Subscription Boxes with Collectibles
Hardcore horror fans want mystery boxes chock-full of goodies, toys, and memorabilia from their favorite horror films. Five years ago, tons of companies offered horror subscription boxes bursting with collectibles. Unfortunately, most of them were bought out by competitors (lots of the old links redirect to Cratejoy), who stopped making the horror boxes or couldn’t survive the rampant inflation of the early 2020s.
But there are still some great subscription boxes available – check them out!
Loot Fright
Loot Crate is a leader in subscription boxes, so it’s no surprise that they offer a horror subscription box. The ghoulishly delicious Loot Fright pack includes a mix of collectibles and apparel from your favorite movies in the genre.
The crate comes once every other month and often includes exclusive items you can only get with the Loot Crate mystery box.
Zobie Fright
Zobie is a new player on the scene, since we didn’t see them when we first wrote this article back in 2022.
Zobie’s fright box comes once a month, and features one autograph along with three collectible items. The items could include anything from t-shirts to prints, pins to figure replicas.
You don’t have to purchase the subscription to enjoy the goodies. If you aren’t sure it’s for you, you can make a one-time box purchase to see what type of items you’ll get.
Cratejoy Horror Plus Book Club
Cratejoy (a fantastic pun showing how the boxes “create” joy) has a fantastic horror book club box that also features a variety of collectibles. Though the main draw of their box is the books, you’ll also get delightful collectibles in each crate.
The collectibles are generally related to niche authors in the horror realm, so if you’re looking for pop culture goodies from big-name hits, this might not be your style.
Culture Fly Supernatural Box
Culture Fly used to have a spectacular subscription box filled with all things horror, but the only box they feature now is exclusive to the hit show Supernatural.
But if you love Supernatural, you will love this box! You’ll get over $100 worth of collectibles from the iconic series delivered right to your doorstep four times a year.
Boxes Bursting with Film and Literature
If you want a subscription of books or movies to satiate your appetite for horror each month, check out these three boxes dedicated to sharing the best of the genre.
Horror Pack
Are you seeking an endless stream of horror movies? You need Horror Pack. This subscription box delivers the best in new, independent, classic horror flicks directly to your door each month.
Horror Pack offers both a DVD and Blu-ray option. The films in each pack are different each month, so if you want double the horror fun, you can always get both.
Night Worms Book Club
Night Worms Book Club offers an exclusive subscription service to fans of horror literature. Each month, the two horror fanatics behind the club send members two great novels. The titles range from true crime to thriller, indie to well-known, but all revolve around the genre.
Night Worms offers exclusives, like signed copies, publisher freebies, and coupons in their package. The only downside is the club’s limited availability. With supplies limited, fans need to act fast when a new box is available to snag it!
Write Your Own Thrilling Stories!
Love horror so much that you want to write your own stories? Check out our bundle of creative writing prompts available on our shop and on Etsy. The full bundle includes Thriller, Horror, and Fantasy writing prompts, but you can also purchase each individually.
Murder Mystery Subscription Boxes
A subset of the horror subscription box is the murder/mystery game, which adds a new spin to the subscription box model by gamifying it. The games below send monthly parcels about a gruesome murder, offering subscribers new evidence each month to help them solve the case. If murder mystery is your jam, you’ll want to check out these two epic game subscription boxes.
This Whodunit is Killer
This Whodunit is Killer is a “to catch a killer” style game, delivering monthly clues to help you solve the crime. Each game is considered a season and typically includes five separate packages.
The packages offer insight into the misdeed, allowing you to narrow your suspect list and ultimately discover the killer.
Hunt a Killer
Hunt a Killer offers their game over a six-month season. The monthly box offers clues and evidence, but in a fun twist, Hunt a Killer also includes a digital component, allowing players to access online evidence and clues through a portal.
There’s also an active Facebook page where people can discuss the case, but please don’t spoil things for new players! If you prefer to play all at once, Hunt a Killer offers box sets of previous seasons, providing the whole experience in one go.
Unique & Eclectic Horror Subscription Boxes
Horror boxes don’t have to be dedicated to games, films, and collectibles. Those looking for unique thrills and items celebrating the macabre outside popular movies might be interested in a horror box satisfying a more niche craving.
Cryptid Crate
Cryptid Crate bursts with oddities, artwork, and collectibles of a paranormal nature. It’s slightly different from the other collectible boxes in that it’s not dedicated to film and literature but more focused on urban legends and mystical happenings, like Bigfoot, aliens, and other supernatural creatures that might lurk among us.
Cryptid Crate also offers a junior box perfect for kids obsessed with otherworldly beings.
The Witches Box
The Witches’ Box isn’t a horror subscription box. It’s a monthly subscription for people who are interested in the real side of magic and witchcraft. Each new box includes spells, rituals, and ingredients to help practitioners perfect their craft and learn more about the magic surrounding us.
Subscribers also gain access to the exclusive online forum, allowing them to interact with the online coven and learn even more about the mysteries surrounding spell work.
Spooky Box Club
The Spooky Box Club offers cute crafts and collectibles all year. The best thing about this box is that many of the items are handmade by craftsmen and artisans. You will get exclusive handcrafted jewelry and original pieces in addition to a selection of teas, candies, pins, bags, and other items.
Each box revolves around a theme, which may be witches, vampires, or anything considered gothic. Spook Box Club aims to be cute, fun, and creative rather than horrific, so although the themes are spooky and Halloweeny, don’t expect objects of terror.
BoneBox
Skulls Unlimited features a unique subscription box filled with real bones. It’s not a typical horror subscription box, as it’s great for armchair biologists and osteologists, but there’s something creepy about getting a box of bones in the mail that horror fans might enjoy.
NME Box
Do you love cosplay and Halloween makeup? NME box is just the ticket. NME stands for “New to Make-up Effects” and sends subscribers, you guessed it, cosplay make-up boxes every month.
The box includes the sponges and brushes you need to apply make-up, all the lip glosses, eye shadows, and foundations you will need, and extra accessories to help you complete the look. It also includes a story prompt to help you get started!
Gothic Beauty
Keeping with the makeup theme, CrateJoy offers a gothic beauty box subscription filled with goodies to help you master the horror look.
In addition to beauty accessories, you’ll also receive a variety of goodies like pins, stickers, cards, and other small items.
More Horror Boxes on Etsy
If you’re looking for a unique spin on horror subscription boxes, consider all the exciting offerings on Etsy. Independent creators make hand-crafted mystery boxes available on both a single purchase and subscription basis.
You can find packages spanning many themes, from gothic to witches, general horror to specific creatures. Most of the boxes are single purchase (so not subscription horror boxes) but a few do pop up from time to time!
Halloween Subscription Boxes
Although horror is the name of the game, sometimes we want something a little more festive. These boxes may not contain scary surprises, but they will help you get into the Halloween spirit and help you celebrate the spooky all year long.
Halloween CraveBox
Halloween Cravebox isn’t a subscription box, but it’s so delicious that it needed to be included. If you’re too old for trick-or-treating but want an epic collection of candy to snack on for the next two weeks, you need the Halloween Cravebox. Filled with snacks ranging from tootsie roll pops to fun-sized bags of cheese-its, these boxes will fill your life with joy.
Be advised that these boxes mostly feature salty snacks and a few pieces of fruity candies. None of the packages include candy bars, usually fan favorites on Halloween.
Order of the Thinned Veil
Cryptocurium’s Order of the Thinned Veil isn’t your typical subscription box. Instead, it’s a membership to an exclusive Halloween order where you receive one to five shipments of spooky goodies (depending on your membership level).
The difference between the Order of the Thinned Veil and other boxes is that you know exactly what you will get when you sign up. The items are featured on the website.
Membership only opens once per year, so sign up early (around Halloween!) to get your spot!
Boo Boxes
“Boo Box” is such a great name for a Halloween subscription box that multiple companies offer their versions. Red vines offers a “Boo Box” filled with licorice, and many gift companies offer Boo Boxes filled with goodies.
Most of these boxes are only offered around Halloween and are not part of a subscription service.
Discontinued Horror Subscription Boxes
Subscription boxes come and go. Your search for a specific box may leave you empty-handed, as these services have disappeared from the landscape.
I’m featuring them because nearly every other article on horror subscription boxes lists them among the “best” (this is why updates are crucial!), so I want you to know that they used to shine, but now (in 2025) no longer exist.
Box of Dread
Although Dread Central is still a top online retailer of horror films and a prolific horror blog, no evidence of their subscription service “Box of Dread” exists on the website. The last Twitter update about the box is from 2018.
Bats & Bones
Bats & Bones seemed like such a cool subscription box! It was dedicated to Wicca and all things occult. Unfortunately, the “most recent” package available on the website is from May of 2022, and it doesn’t look like anything is in stock.
Fright Club
The Fright Club horror subscription box was supplied by now-defunct online retailer Creepies. In 2022, the website said they’d bring the horror box back, but in 2025, I can no longer even find the website.
Pumpkin Cult Boo Box
This subscription box offered Halloween goodies year-round, but it’s no longer available.
Zchest
Zchest was a zombie-themed subscription box offered via Cratejoy. It’s no longer available.
Rue Morgue Coffin Box
Rue Morgue is a world leader in horror magazines, and in 2023, they introduced a horror subscription box to accompany it. Unfortunately, I can no longer find the box on their website.
All Hallows Club
All Hallows Club was an Australian-based website offering a quarterly subscription box of cute decor, prints, and other Halloween-themed items. Though the website no longer exists, the artist behind it is still active on Facebook.
Creepy Crate
Creepy Crate guaranteed a spooky story with each box, but the website is now defunct.
The Bam! Box
The Bam! Box was a subscription box service dedicated to autographs. They had a great horror autograph set, but now the website redirects to Cratejoy.
My Thrill Club
My Thrill Club offered three horror novels each month, but the website no longer exists.
Box of Goth
Box of Goth offered subscription and individual boxes all revolving around spooky and scary gothic themes, but don’t even try to go to the URL, it redirects to some Russian gambling site.
Subscription Boxes Abound!
Subscription services are popular because they offer clients something they can’t get anywhere else: anticipation. Nothing beats the intrigue around unwrapping a new gift each month. Although the boxes on this list are dedicated to the horror genre, you can find subscriptions geared towards nearly any niche you can imagine.
Relive the magic of unwrapping presents on Christmas morning by giving yourself the gift of a subscription box.